Quotes attributable to Timothy Roberts, President NSWCCL 

“Political speech must be protected. This is an absurd situation where someone, in their private capacity, asked a question about an intelligence agency and has subsequently been targeted, censored and publicly condemned by their employer. 

“It is in the public’s interest for questions to be asked regarding the trustworthiness of information from the government, including from intelligence agencies. This year alone it has been exposed that the Dural Caravan incident was known to be a criminal hoax from early on, while the NSW Premier used this to inflame fear in the public and push through anti-protest laws. 

“In a democratic country, we are entitled to question and scrutinize the decisions of all states. Even more so, we are entitled to question and scrutinize the decisions of intelligence agencies. 

“Across Australia we are witnessing institutions, including hospitals, cave to pressure and use codes of conduct and policies to repress legitimate political speech. This is shameful, antidemocratic behaviour.

“As a matter of public policy, definitions which conflate criticism of Israel and its government’s policies with antisemitism are of serious concern to freedom of speech, in the circumstance of Peter Macdonald this is taken even further to equate criticism of the Israeli intelligence agency Mossad, with antisemitism.”