Today, the High Court has handed down its decision in Ravbar & Anor v Commonwealth of Australia & ORS [2025], otherwise known as the case testing the legality of the CFMEU administration. The High Court found the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Amendment (Administration) Act 2024 is constitutionally valid. 

The NSW Council for Civil Liberties (NSWCCL) remains seriously concerned about the administration and its implications for all member-based civil society organisations, unions, and registered clubs. Last year, the Commonwealth removed democratic control of the CFMEU by its members on the basis of what were at the time, untested allegations. The findings of the High Court do not negate that the CFMEU was placed into administration without, at the time the legislation was passed, any proven allegations of wrongdoing. The appropriate response from the government should have been to test the allegations against CFMEU officials and delegates in court, and if proven, sought the removal of the officials. This process was circumvented when administration was imposed by parliament, and went against the essential democratic principles of innocence until proven guilty, due process and freedom of association. The administration legislation may now operate as a legal model for the takeover of other unions and other member-based civil society organisations in the future. 

Over the past twelve months there has been a worrying trend of state overreach by the federal Labor Government, which threatens to undermine the rule of law, including through the passing of the Administration Act and the introductions of mandatory minimum sentencing late last year. The NSWCCL maintains that everyone has the right to natural justice and procedural fairness, regardless of the allegations they face. 

The independence of membership-based organisations across Australia must be protected and Australia must uphold its obligations under the International Labour Organisation, namely Articles 3 and 4 of the Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention, 1948.